Fire and Rescue Best Value
All Right Honourable and Honourable Members will recognise the importance of having well-functioning Fire and Rescue Services which provide essential services local communities rely upon and lives ultimately depend on. Today, I am announcing to the House a Best Value Inspection of West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority.
The relationship between the Authority and West Midlands Fire and Rescue Service has come under intense local and national scrutiny in recent months. Whilst the Service continues to protect and respond to the needs of its local community, there is concern that the Authority, in its oversight and scrutiny of the service, may have failed to deliver against its key Best Value Functions of economy, efficiency and effectiveness.
In response to this, the Secretary of State under section 26 of the Local Government Act 1999 (“the 1999 Act”), has ordered a Best Value Inspection of West Midlands Fire and Rescue Authority. This independent Inspection will examine the Authority’s compliance with its Best Value duty to ensure that any failings are identified, addressed and rectified. This focus on governance differentiates this Inspection from His Majesty’s Inspectorate of Fire and Rescue Services’ report published on 18 June 2025, which focussed on operations. The Inspection’s recommendations may additionally identify broader lessons that can be applied across other fire and rescue services.
The Secretary of State has exercised her powers contained within Section 10 of the 1999 Act to appoint Fenella Morris KC as the Lead Inspector, Anna Bicarregui and Gethin Thomas as Assistant Inspectors, and Tasnim Shawkat as Assistant Inspector (Monitoring Officer). It is intended that the Inspection will deliver its recommendations during the first quarter of 2026.
Conclusion
I want to acknowledge the work of the dedicated staff of West Midlands Fire and Rescue Service who continue to deliver this vital service for their local communities. This Inspection will ensure that the lessons from the past are learned and any improvements that need to be made are swiftly implemented.
I will place in the House Library, copies of the terms of reference, and in time, reports and associated materials.